Consignment selling is judged first on what lands in your bank account once the car is sold, and on how long it takes to get there. One garage may quote a low rate and then add fees at every step. Another may take more, but with everything included. This article explains how a garage gets paid on a consignment sale, which fees to have priced before you sign, and how to compare two offers on the same basis.
The right question is not the rate, it is the net amount you receive
A percentage on its own does not tell you how much you will get. What counts is the net amount: the sale price, minus everything the garage keeps or charges.
Take two offers. The first shows a modest rate, but charges separately for preparation, photos and storage. The second shows a higher fee and adds nothing on top. The second can easily leave you with more money.
As a reminder, consignment means handing your car to a garage, which sells it on your behalf. You remain the owner until the sale, and you are normally paid once the buyer has paid, as the contract provides. The full mechanism is explained in the article on how a consignment sale works.
Three ways to pay the garage
There are three mechanisms, sometimes combined. None is better in absolute terms. Each one pushes the garage in a different direction.
A percentage of the sale price achieved
The garage keeps a share of the price paid by the buyer. The higher the car sells, the more it earns. So it has an interest in defending the price.
Get it in writing: the rate, the amount it applies to (advertised price or price actually paid) and whether there is a minimum in francs.
A fixed fee, whatever the price
The garage receives an amount agreed in advance, whether the car sells high or low. It has no direct interest in selling for more. Its main interest is selling fast.
Get it in writing: the amount of the fee, what it covers, and whether it is still owed if the car does not sell.
An agreed net amount for the seller
You and the garage set the amount you want to receive. It is written into the contract. The garage's fee comes out of the sale price achieved, above that amount. So the garage has an interest in selling above your net, and you know in advance what you will receive.
Get it in writing: the net amount in francs, who can change it and how, and what happens if no buyer accepts a high enough price.
When the price moves: who absorbs the difference
The example below is purely a hypothetical calculation. The amounts are rounded to make it easier to read. They are neither actual prices charged by garages nor market averages.
A car is targeted at 30,000 francs. We compare three offers: a 10% percentage, a fixed fee of 2,500 francs, and an agreed net of 27,000 francs.
The car sells for 32,000 francs
- Percentage: the garage keeps 3,200 francs, you are left with 28,800 francs.
- Fixed fee: the garage keeps 2,500 francs, you are left with 29,500 francs.
- Agreed net: you receive 27,000 francs, the garage keeps the remaining 5,000 francs.
The car sells for 28,000 francs
- Percentage: the garage keeps 2,800 francs, you are left with 25,200 francs.
- Fixed fee: the garage keeps 2,500 francs, you are left with 25,500 francs.
- Agreed net: you still receive 27,000 francs, the garage keeps only 1,000 francs.
What the example shows
The agreed net protects your amount. In return, the upside goes to the garage: at 32,000 francs, the agreed net leaves you less than the other two options. It also requires a realistic price: if no buyer pays more than your net, the car does not sell, or the net will have to be lowered.
The percentage shares both the upside and the downside between you and the garage.
The fixed fee weighs more heavily on an inexpensive car. At 2,500 francs, it represents about 8% of the price of a 30,000 franc car, but 25% of a 10,000 franc car.
In all three cases, the floor price plays a central role. It is explained in the article on how consignment works mentioned above.
Additional fees to have priced before you sign
Depending on the garage, other costs may be added to the fee. For each one, ask three questions: is it included, charged separately, or deducted from the sale price?
- Preparation and cleaning: a basic clean, a full detailing job or minor touch-ups do not cost the same.
- Photos, video and listings: often included, sometimes charged, especially for paid listings.
- Showroom storage: a first period is sometimes free, then charged monthly.
- Inspection: if the last one is old or the car needs to go back for its official inspection, who arranges it and who pays?
- Outstanding lease or loan: the balance to be settled with the finance company and the costs linked to the transaction. For orders of magnitude, see what it costs to settle a lease early.
Not all preparation costs are equal. Some are recovered in the sale price, others are not. For details, read the article on the preparation costs you actually get back.
What a car that does not sell costs you
An offer should also be judged on the failure scenario. An unsold car can cost you money.
- Costs already incurred: preparation, photos, listings. Depending on the contract, these may remain payable by you.
- Accumulated storage: at the showroom, every month beyond the free period adds up.
- A sum owed on withdrawal: some contracts provide for an amount if you find a buyer yourself, or if you take the car back before the end of the mandate.
There is also a cost nobody invoices: time. While the car waits, it ages, sometimes adds kilometres, and loses value. A sale that drags on for several months can wipe out the advantage of a higher net.
How these points are worded in the contract is covered in the article on the consignment contract clauses to check.
Comparing two offers on a single basis
For each offer, fill in the following three lines:
- Net amount received if the car sells at the target price, after all fees.
- Costs you pay regardless, even without a sale.
- Payment delay between the sale and the transfer to your account.
The winning offer is not always the one showing the biggest net. A net set too high guarantees you nothing: it slows the sale down, and can end in a negotiated reduction months later. A realistic offer that sells within a few weeks often brings in more than a promise that finds no taker.
To check that the target price holds up, see what determines the price of a used car.
Consignment, private sale, garage buyback: net amount versus time
Selling privately leaves you the full price, but you handle the listings, viewings, test drives and payment risks. A garage buying your car pays quickly, but less, since the garage buys in order to resell. Consignment sits between the two: a higher net than a garage buyback, less work than a private sale, but a timeline that depends on the market.
In short, the more of the work you do yourself, the higher the final amount. The full comparison is in the article private sale, garage buyback or consignment: the three options.
At SwissMcars: a net amount agreed and written into the contract
At SwissMcars, the net amount you will receive is agreed with you and written into the consignment contract: that is what you get once the car is sold. The garage's fee comes out of the sale price achieved.
Two options are available. With online consignment, the car stays with you while it is being marketed. With showroom consignment, it is displayed on our premises and storage is free for the first month. In both cases, you can end the consignment without notice after one month, or with 7 days' notice before that.
Once the car is sold, you receive a statement of the sale and you are paid within 24 hours of the payment being received.
Full details are on the page about consignment as practised at SwissMcars. For real examples, see the cars already sold on consignment.
Want to know what net amount is realistic for your car? The simplest way is to talk to the garage about your car.


